A very common question that seems to come up a lot in Facebook groups, particularly tradie groups, is whether lead generation websites are any good.
I'm not going to name any companies or businesses that run lead generation websites, but there are a few key ones out there, probably five top ones. I won't name names; this is going to be a podcast about my experience and what people are saying about these services online.
These companies essentially act as a middleman or a bridge from you getting to your lead. What they do is seek out leads online. They get their clients to fill out a form, which then might be diverted to, say, 10 tradies. Then it becomes a battle over who gets the lead. I've had experience with these companies many years ago. I used them when I first started my business. It seemed an easy pathway to get some leads. So, you go to these websites, sign up, give your details, credit card information, and the area you service.
Then, as leads come in—whether they're real or not, who knows?—you get alerted on the app of the company. It's like the fastest finger first. To top it off, you could pay anywhere from $15 to $50 just to get the lead's contact details. So you can contact them, but from experience, I've found that they've often already locked in the job with someone else.
So that $50 is down the drain.
Whoever gets back to the lead the quickest is probably in with the best chance, but not necessarily. Many of the leads I received were very poor quality, just people kicking around for a price. My experience wasn't positive. Before this podcast, I did some digging around in Facebook groups and summarized the feedback on a particular company, which I won't name.
But it's a common question that gets asked: Is X, Y, Z company any good? People thinking about signing up often hear that it seems too good to be true. People starting businesses without much understanding of marketing see this as an easy way out, instead of putting effort into their own marketing, which is a shame because it means cutting out the middleman.
These companies are middlemen; they basically pump SEO, pump ads, and then you pay them for the leads they gather, which gets watered down because it's shared with three to ten other tradies.
To break it down, let's say hypothetically they're getting cheap clicks for those cheap keywords. They convert and get a call from that first click. Let's say they paid $40 for that click when somebody clicks on that ad on Google. It then takes them to a landing page, prompting the client to fill out a form.
They fill out the form, then it gets churned out to X amount of tradies, let's say 10. They charge each tradie, hypothetically, $40 for the lead. If 10 tradies get that lead for $40 each, they've all paid $40. So, the company makes $400 minus their $40 cost, making a profit of $360. This is how their model operates.
And this is why the more leads, the better for them. They don't care about the quality—cheap, nasty, good, it doesn't matter. As long as they're getting leads and turning them over to contractors, the quality of the lead doesn't matter to them.
And that's the most disappointing thing about these services: the quality of the leads is very poor.
An interesting point is the types of keywords they target in their ads. If you go to your browser, like Google Chrome, Safari, etc., and type in "cheap plumber," "cheap electrician," "cheap tiler," "three free quotes," "cheap," just all those keywords, followed by your trade, and then search for things like "cheap tap washer replacement," "cheap PowerPoint installation," "cheap tiler," "cheap carpenter," "cheap landscaper in [suburb here]."
You'll notice a pattern in these companies' advertising. They attract people looking for a quick, cheap response. They make it look so easy, and in some ads, they include enticements like "find electricians from $60 an hour," and "plumbers from $60 an hour."
If you're a tradie charging $60 an hour, you're in the wrong game. It's not feasible to survive in business on that. They entice leads by dangling the carrot of getting the cheapest, best tradie in the land, offering instant quotes, quotes within 30 seconds. When the lead gets pinged out, everyone is desperate for business, especially those just starting and using these lead generation websites. They get their quotes or inquiries probably within about five minutes because people are sitting there, waiting by their phone for these leads, instead of focusing on their own marketing plan, building a website, Google My Business profiles, Facebook, Instagram, etc., working on their own thing.
Instead, they're just putting money into this, which is going to be a race to the bottom. Now, I'm going to go through some points that I've taken from the Facebook threads and read through themselves, summarizing a lot of them. So I'm just going to run through the feedback that's been given for these websites.
Let's start with the negative points. Many users have a negative experience with company X, often expressing strong dissatisfaction. Customers tend to look for the cheapest prices, leading to price pressure on contractors. Some users report that leads are overpriced, and there's a lack of transparency regarding credit expiring. The system is criticized for encouraging quote chopping and attracting price-driven customers, which we hate. Contractors complain about competition from others, including those who don't value their license and are unlicensed. Company X is seen as a corporation trying to take a cut out of the action between contractors and customers. Some users warn against locking into a 12-month contract and recommend focusing on a website and Google ads instead. Company X is described as a community for price shoppers, and many users advise against using it. Additionally, users have expressed concerns about company X sharing their contact details with various companies, resulting in unwanted calls, spam, and emails.
There are reports that company X attracts customers who demand free quotes and challenge every price provided. It's viewed as a platform to encourage a race to the bottom in terms of pricing, which can devalue the said trade industry. In summary, the majority of the comments indicate a negative perception of company X, with many contractors finding it challenging to maintain profitability due to the focus on low prices. Users recommend exploring alternative lead generation methods, such as creating a decent website, using Google advertising, and creating a marketing plan.
So, some of the positive points are that it can be beneficial to use these services if you don't have a website or any type of marketing going on. But, to be honest, that's your own fault. That's laziness for not creating a website or doing any of your own marketing. You can create a website for a few hundred dollars and have it up and running in a day with the likes of AI and so on. It's gone crazy. Jump on YouTube if you want to do it on a budget, and you'll have a website up and running in a few hours. It can generate leads, get clicks and inquiries, but again, you're sharing those leads with everybody else. Some users have experienced repeat customers from company X.
I nearly said it, lads.
Some users have experienced repeat clients. Now, I'm going to speak about my own experience on this. I used these companies at the very start, almost got catfished into thinking it was a good thing before I actually started the company. I signed up to two of these providers and started getting leads while I was working full-time. I thought this was fantastic, so easy. At the time, I didn't know what I should have been pricing. I was actually the typical cheaply priced tradesman going into these jobs, and I was winning these jobs, thinking, "This is easy." This is commonly what happens: the lower prices win the jobs. I didn't even realize it was low. I thought I was balling because I was comparing what I was getting paid in wages versus what was going into my bank account per hour. So if it was $60 an hour, I thought I was winning, which is very foolish looking back. You have to learn these things.
And that's what I'm trying to emphasize. I'm hoping this will get through to someone thinking about signing up to these lead generation websites and make them think, "Let's not do this. It's not a good idea." But I have actually picked up two or three existing clients from those services, back in the day. Now, I would say statistically, one in every 30 leads is a golden client that just happened to stumble across those services and put in an inquiry there. And you've happened to pick up that client. Other than that, it's very hit and miss. You're going to get some nasty clients that are going to squeeze you on price. I've heard stories of people actually getting the job, agreeing on the price, and then getting haggled once again at the end. So, that's a nasty place to be. It's not a good headspace. When you go to work, you're dreading going to the job for starters, you're wondering if you're going to make money, and then to get haggled at the end, it's very bad for your mental health and your bottom line.
Our ideal client for our electrical business is someone who values quality, who shows up on time, does a good job, cleans up. Price comes down the line. It doesn't necessarily matter that much about price because they care more about a great job being done.
So the question to ask yourself before signing up to any of these platforms is, who is your ideal client? And are they going to be looking for you on these services? I highly doubt it.